Study finds collapsible cycle helmets offer less protection

Collapsible bicycle helmets offer less protection against serious head injuries on average than conventional designs, according to new research from Imperial College London.
However, researchers found that the performance gap was not inherent to foldable designs. Lighter helmets with added rotational protection technology could improve safety, with one collapsible model ranking second among all 30 helmets tested.
All helmets in the study met minimum regulatory safety standards. The researchers also stressed that wearing a helmet provides better protection than wearing none.
Collapsible helmets offer portability and convenience, particularly for people using cycle hire schemes. The models purchased for the study cost an average of £101, compared with £64 for conventional helmets.
The study, funded by The Road Safety Trust, compared 24 conventional models with all six collapsible models available in the UK. Researchers from Imperial’s Dyson School of Design Engineering tested the helmets to simulate common head impacts experienced by cyclists in crashes.
This study will feed into the HEAD Lab’s Helmet Impact Protection Effectiveness Rating (HIPER) system, established with funding from The Road Safety Trust, which provides consumers with safety data on different helmet models to make informed purchasing decisions, and manufacturers with insights to improve future helmet designs.
The lead author, Dr William Dawber, from Imperial’s Dyson School of Design Engineering, said: “Collapsible helmets are a great solution to overcome inconvenience; one of the most reported reasons people in urban areas don’t wear helmets when they want to ride a bicycle.
“Until now, there has been no way for the wearer to judge how well the different designs protect them against severe head injuries, which is the entire point of wearing a helmet. I am delighted that we can share the findings of our research so people can choose a helmet that fits with their budget and lifestyle.”
Ruth Purdie OBE, Chief Executive of The Road Safety Trust, said: “We are pleased to see the HIPER rating system for cycle helmets continue to grow and evolve.
“Backed by world-class research, it is addressing important and timely issues such as foldable helmets, whose growing popularity makes clear, independent evidence about their safety performance for consumers and manufacturers increasingly vital.”
This work builds on previous HEAD Lab research published in Annals of Biomedical Engineering in 2024, which found that helmet price was not a reliable indicator of protection offered by helmets and that some helmets reduced rotational risks much better than others.
What the tests found
The average predicted risk of linear injuries was 24% for collapsible helmets, compared with 20% for conventional helmets. These injuries include skull fractures and focal brain injuries associated with the head’s linear motion during a crash.
The study found no difference between the groups in protection against brain injuries caused by head rotation. Overall, five of the six collapsible helmets ranked in the bottom half for protection.
Researchers identified greater weight and limited use of rotational protection technology as factors contributing to the lower average performance of collapsible helmets.
Collapsible helmets weighed an average of 461 grams, compared with 294 grams for conventional models. Greater helmet mass was associated with higher linear injury risk.
Rotational protection technologies reduced both linear and rotational injury risks, but featured in only one of the six collapsible helmets, compared with 12 of the 24 conventional models.
Scope for safer designs
Testing two versions of the same collapsible helmet demonstrated the potential for improvement. The version fitted with the Multi-directional Impact Protection System (MIPS) ranked second out of 30 helmets, while the version without it ranked 26th.
The findings suggest that lighter designs incorporating rotational protection could help combine the convenience of collapsible helmets with improved safety performance.
Professor Mazdak Ghajari, Professor of Brain Biomechanics at the Dyson School of Design Engineering and a founder of the HEAD Lab, added: “Any helmet is safer than no helmet and innovative designs that appeal to more people are to be applauded. Underpinning HIPER is our aim to help manufacturers improve the safety of their products and for retailers to use our new clearer ratings in informing customers to make the right choices. We couldn’t do that without the collective years of engineering knowledge and research and connections with brain scientists we have at Imperial.”
Helping cyclists make informed choices
The HEAD Lab’s updated HIPER rating system awards diamond, platinum, gold, silver and bronze medals based on safety performance, giving consumers more detail than the pass/fail results used in regulatory certification.
Current certification tests use vertical drops that primarily measure direct impact forces. The Imperial team instead tested helmets at four impact locations, measuring both linear and rotational head motion to better reflect real-world crashes.
Each impact was repeated three times using a new helmet sample to account for manufacturing and testing variability.